Edition: International | Greek

Home » Business

Google wins landmark ‘right to be forgotten’ case in blow for privacy advocates

Google has fended off a landmark legal challenge from the French data protection authority after the EU’s top court ruled that the search engine giant does not have to apply ‘right to be forgotten’ rules globally

By: EBR - Posted: Tuesday, September 24, 2019

The disagreement between the CNIL and Google then led to a €100,000 fine from the French data protection watchdog.
The disagreement between the CNIL and Google then led to a €100,000 fine from the French data protection watchdog.

by Samuel Stolton

The ruling comes after a protracted standoff between Google and the Commission nationale de l’informatique et des libertes (CNIL), which dates back to 2015, when the French data protection watchdog ordered Google to remove sensitive data about an individual – across all of its domains worldwide.

Subsequent to the 2015 challenge, Google sought to mitigate concerns by introducing a geoblocking feature that would hide de-referenced links from European users – not, however, censoring results for those based outside of Europe.

The disagreement between the CNIL and Google then led to a €100,000 fine from the French data protection watchdog.

On Tuesday, both sides came to a head and the EU’s highest court ruled that under the bloc’s General Data Protection Regulation, Google is not “required to carry out a de-referencing on all versions of its search engine.”

However, the judgement adds that “EU law requires a search engine operator to carry out such a de-referencing on the versions of its search engine corresponding to all the member states.”

The ruling follows an opinion submitted by the court’s highest advisor, Advocate General Maciej Szpunar in January, in which he said that he was “not in favour of giving the provisions of EU law such a broad interpretation” and that the court “should limit the scope of the de-referencing that search engine operators are required to carry out, to the EU.”

In a related case on Tuesday, the Court of Justice of the EU also ruled that based on Article 8 of the bloc’s 1996 Data Protection Directive, Google is prohibited from the “processing of personal data revealing racial or ethnic origin, political opinions, religious or philosophical beliefs, or trade-union membership, and the processing of data concerning health or sex life.”

Following the rulings, the European branch of the Computer and Communication Industry Association (CCIA) said that the decision “honours EU residents’ “right to be forgotten” without compromising the constitutional rights of citizens outside of the EU.”

*first published in: www.euractiv.com


Editor’s Column

The Brexit negotiations near to an end…

N. Peter KramerBy: N. Peter Kramer

On Sunday, Prime Minister Boris Johnson told his cabinet that while he could see a ‘pathway’ to a deal, there was ‘still a significant amount of work’ needed to get there

View 03/2019 2019 Digital edition


Current Issue

03/2019 2019

View past issues
Digital edition


If the EU disappeared, would anyone care?

If the EU disappeared, would anyone care?

Despite the largest voter turnout in the European elections, 60% of Europeans aren’t sure they would miss the EU if it were gone


Crowdfunding for Impact?

Crowdfunding for Impact?

Individuals seem increasingly keen to invest in ventures that create social impact, and crowdfunding platforms are making this easier than ever


Powered by Investing.com
All contents © Copyright EMG Strategic Consulting Ltd. 1997-2019. All Rights Reserved   |   Home Page  |   Disclaimer  |   Website by Theratron