Edition: International | Greek
MENU

Home » EU Actually

The double standards of the European Commission

Europhiles and other ardent supporters of the EU have reacted with horror and disbelief at the ruling of the German Constitutional Court in Karlsruhe that the European Central Bank’s bond buying programme failed a ‘proportionality test’ by not taking into account its broad economic effect

By: N. Peter Kramer - Posted: Wednesday, May 20, 2020

For Germans, the constitutional court is the most respected institution in the country, together with the Bundesbank, the German central bank. For the EU to humble the most important pillar of Germany’s post-war stability would invite a public backlash.
For Germans, the constitutional court is the most respected institution in the country, together with the Bundesbank, the German central bank. For the EU to humble the most important pillar of Germany’s post-war stability would invite a public backlash.

by N. Peter Kamer

Europhiles and other ardent supporters of the EU have reacted with horror and disbelief at the ruling of the German Constitutional Court in Karlsruhe that the European Central Bank’s bond buying programme failed a ‘proportionality test’ by not taking into account its broad economic effect. The court also stated that the European Court of Justice had been acting beyond its authority, when it declared the ECB bond buying legal. The EU view, expressed by European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, is that the ECJ is the higher court and outranks Karlsruhe.

If the EU responds as Von der Leyen threatened, with an infringement proceeding against Germany, the dispute between the ECJ and Karlsruhe would be arbitrated by the ECJ itself. That would completely undermine the moral force of its ruling. It is also nearly unthinkable the European Commission is going to sue the German government for a ruling by a national court. In a modern democracy, is not the judiciary independent from the two other powers according to the ‘trias politica’, Montesquieu’s system of separation of powers ? Isn’t this exactly the reason for the Commission’s infringement case against the current Polish government who want to influence the country’s courts? It seems that the Commission employs two opposite standards for infringement.

For Germans, the constitutional court is the most respected institution in the country, together with the Bundesbank, the German central bank. For the EU to humble the most important pillar of Germany’s post-war stability would invite a public backlash. The EU can survive a Brexit, but without Germany there would be no EU.

READ ALSO

EU Actually

Does Vestager overplay her hand again?

N. Peter KramerBy: N. Peter Kramer

The EU General Court overturned the landmark 2016 decision by EU competition commissioner Margrethe Vestager that Ireland should claw back €13 billion in unpaid taxes plus interest from Apple

View 01/2020 2020 Digital edition

Magazine

Current Issue

01/2020 2020

View past issues
Subscribe
Advertise
Digital edition

Europe

The EU can and must cut emissions by more than 55% by 2030

The EU can and must cut emissions by more than 55% by 2030

The European Commission has proposed to strengthen its 40% greenhouse gas emission reduction target to 50% or 55% on 1990 levels in the next ten years

Business

COVID-19 has disrupted cybersecurity, too – here’s how businesses can decrease their risk

COVID-19 has disrupted cybersecurity, too – here’s how businesses can decrease their risk

COVID-19 is changing everything. Along with social distancing, obsessive sanitisation, broken supply chains, fragmented workforces and the rise of video meetings, the pandemic is driving acute systemic changes in consumer and business behavior

MARKET INDICES

Powered by Investing.com
All contents © Copyright EMG Strategic Consulting Ltd. 1997-2020. All Rights Reserved   |   Home Page  |   Disclaimer  |   Website by Theratron