Edition: International | Greek
MENU

Home » Europe

EU ‘Green Label’ for nuclear energy?

What position does nuclear energy have in the fight against global warming? A heated debate about this question takes place in the EU and many of its member states

By: N. Peter Kramer - Posted: Wednesday, March 31, 2021

"In 2019, a quarter of electricity production in the EU was generated by nuclear energy. Proponents say it is ‘indispensable’ to become climate neutral by 2050, nuclear energy is not only CO2 neutral but also unlike solar and wind energy permanently available."
"In 2019, a quarter of electricity production in the EU was generated by nuclear energy. Proponents say it is ‘indispensable’ to become climate neutral by 2050, nuclear energy is not only CO2 neutral but also unlike solar and wind energy permanently available."

by N. Peter Kramer

What position does nuclear energy have in the fight against global warming? A heated debate about this question takes place in the EU and many of its member states. In 2019, a quarter of electricity production in the EU was generated by nuclear energy. Proponents say it is ‘indispensable’ to become climate neutral by 2050, nuclear energy is not only CO2 neutral but also unlike solar and wind energy permanently available.

With its Green Deal, the European Commission has outlined a roadmap to achieve the ambitious goal for 2050, but it does not state which technology the member states should use to achieve it. Climate Commissioner Frans Timmermans says ‘the Commission is technology-neutral, the choice is up to the countries themselves.

‘Brussels’ has to go further than that, seven member states including France, Hungary and Poland say in a recent letter to the Commission. ‘The EU must not only recognise climate-neutral technologies, it must also actively support them’. French President Emmanuel Macron, Prime Minister Victor Orban and the other five government leaders ask the Commission to label nuclear energy as a ‘sustainable investment’ in the so-called EU taxonomy.

With this classification system, the Commission wants to uniformly define what green investments are, in order to encourage public and private investors to consider projects ‘that have proven to be sustainable’.

The call from the seven member states comes at a time when the Commission wants to put the final touches to that taxonomy. Solar and wind farms will certainly count as sustainable projects, and nuclear energy plants should be treated in the same way, advocates the letter.

However, the opponents of nuclear energy including Germany and Austria, disagree, partly because of the environmental impact of nuclear waste, which remains radioactive for centuries, is said to be insufficiently taken into account.

The Commission asked its scientific research centre, the Joint Research Centre (JRC), to prepare a report. A leaked version of the report obtained by Reuters, shows that the JRC will recommend giving nuclear energy a green label. ‘The analyses did not reveal any scientific evidence that nuclear energy is more harmful to human health or the environment than other power generation technologies’, the report said.

The researchers find storage deep underground ‘appropriate and safe’, ‘although there is no long-term operational experience’. Serious nuclear accidents, such as a decade ago in Fukushima, Japan, ‘cannot be ruled out one hundred percent’, says the JRC, but are ‘very unlikely’.

Two expert committees must now review the JRC’s report before the Commission takes a decision.

READ ALSO

EU Actually

EU climate law agreement: Council did not give in

N. Peter KramerBy: N. Peter Kramer

Last night, the negotiators of the European Parliament and Council reached a provisional political agreement on the objective of a climate-neutral EU by 2050 and a collective net greenhouse gas emissions reduction target of at least 55% by 2030 compared to 1990

View 01-02/2021 2021 Digital edition

Magazine

Current Issue

01-02/2021 2021

View past issues
Subscribe
Advertise
Digital edition

Europe

Europe fit for the Digital Age

Europe fit for the Digital Age

Commission proposes new rules and actions for excellence and trust in Artificial Intelligence

Business

Li Shufu is pulling the strings at Volvo, Mercedes and Lotus

Li Shufu is pulling the strings at Volvo, Mercedes and Lotus

Will carmaker Volvo get a stock exchange listing in Stockholm, or may be in Amsterdam, as Bloomberg news agency claims?

MARKET INDICES

Powered by Investing.com
All contents © Copyright EMG Strategic Consulting Ltd. 1997-2021. All Rights Reserved   |   Home Page  |   Disclaimer  |   Website by Theratron